Women with colored hair comparing Aveda vs Redken hair color

Aveda vs Redken hair color: Comparison

Aveda vs Redken hair color: the showdown. Hair color masks your grays and not to forget gives you a completely new look. But this change of color might damage your hair with no turning back. This is all due to the bad-quality ingredients and harsh chemicals that make your hair like a broom. Therefore, choosing the right brand becomes crucial. 

Today there’s an intoxicating abundance of options in the market. They promise everything from radiant shine to long-lasting coverage. Yet, two brands consistently rise above the foliage: Aveda vs Redken. If you are also looking for the best hair color among these, then this guide will help to make the decision. Here we are providing a comprehensive Aveda vs Redken hair color comparison. However, we would like to state here that we do not support indulging in hair coloring too much. Always do a patch test and only after that go for it. Let’s dive deeper into this. 

Aveda hair color Review:

Aveda hair color bottle in blue color

Aveda Full Spectrum Permanent Hair Color is a well-known brand that is almost completely plant-based. With a claim of being up to 99% naturally derived, this provides a bright shine with minimal damage. Their formulas are infused with botanical oils.

The ingredients of the products are vegan, thus ensuring the color shines with a clear conscience. The hues are fade-resistant to a great extent and being naturally derived makes them kind to the environment.

The brand is B Corp certified, which indicates their ethical practices. They are Leaping Bunny-approved as well, indicating that the products are cruelty-free. Therefore, Aveda hair color is kind to your hair as well as our earth as they ditch petrochemicals for plant power.

Ingredients:

Coloring Agents:

  • M-Aminophenol (Monoethanolamine): A developer that helps the color pigments react and penetrate the hair shaft. Can be harsh on sensitive scalps.
  • P-Aminophenol (Para-Aminophenol): Another developer, essential for achieving permanent hair color.
  • Resorcinol: A dye precursor that helps create vibrant colors, but can irritate skin and eyes.
  • Toluene-2,5-Diamin Sulfate (Toluenediamine): A potent dye precursor for dark and intense shades, but can cause allergic reactions.

Oxidants:

  • Ammonium Hydroxide (Ammonia): Opens the hair cuticle to allow color penetration, but can be harsh and damaging.
  • Sodium Sulfite: A stabilizer that prevents premature oxidation of color components.

Conditioning and Protective Ingredients:

  • Aspalathus Linearis (Red Tea) Leaf Extract: Antioxidant with anti-inflammatory properties, potentially soothing the scalp.
  • Camellia Sinensis (Green Tea) Leaf Extract: Antioxidant with anti-inflammatory and scalp-soothing properties.
  • Cetearyl Alcohol: Thickener and emulsifier that helps keep the color mixture smooth and creamy.
  • Cocamide Mea: Mild surfactant that helps cleanse and disperse color evenly.
  • Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil: Moisturizing and nourishing ingredients to help prevent dryness and damage.
  • Copernicia Cerifera Cera (Carnauba Wax): Thickener and film-forming agent that adds shine and manageability.
  • Decyl Glucoside: Mild surfactant that helps cleanse and disperse color evenly.
  • Erythorbic Acid (Vitamin C): Antioxidant that helps protect hair from damage.
  • Glycerin: Humectant that attracts moisture to the hair, keeping it hydrated and supple.
  • Glyceryl Stearate: Emollient that softens and smooths the hair.
  • Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seed Oil: Rich in fatty acids, it nourishes and protects the hair.
  • Hydrolyzed Soy Protein: Strengthens and repairs damaged hair.
  • Maltodextrin: Binder and thickener that helps stabilize the color formula.
  • Oleic Acid: Emollient that helps soften and smooth the hair.
  • Orbignya Oleifera (Babassu) Seed Oil: Moisturizing and nourishing oil that helps prevent dryness and damage.
  • Ricinus Communis (Castor) Seed Oil: Thickener and conditioning agent that adds shine and manageability.
  • Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil: Nourishing and moisturizing oil that closely resembles sebum, the hair’s natural oil.
  • Vanillin: Fragrance ingredient that adds a pleasant vanilla scent.

Other Ingredients:

  • Steareth-21: Emulsifier that helps blend the oil and water phases of the formula.
  • Tetrasodium Edta: Chelating agent that binds to metal ions in water, preventing discoloration and ensuring color stability.
  • Water\Aqua\Eau: The main solvent in the formula, carrying other ingredients and facilitating their application.

Pros:

  • Up to 99% naturally derived formulas. 
  • Formula Derived from plant oils for minimal damage
  • The natural formula gives a radiant shine.
  • The color is Fade-Resistant. 
  • Uses plant power instead of petrochemicals. 
  • Certified B Corp™ product. 
  • Leaping Bunny approval for cruelty-free practices.
  • All ingredients are plant-based, thus 100% vegan. 
  • Wide range of shades to choose from. 
  • Nourishing formulations minimize the potential for damage and dryness.
  • Natural Ingredients like Aspalathus Linearis (Red Tea) Leaf Extract, Camellia Sinensis (Green Tea) Leaf Extract, Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil, Copernicia Cerifera Cera (Carnauba Wax), Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seed Oil, Orbignya Oleifera (Babassu) Seed Oil, Ricinus Communis (Castor) Seed Oil, and Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil.

Cons:

  • Generally more expensive than conventional hair color brands.
  • May not be as readily available as mainstream brands in all regions.
  • Many shades still contain ammonia, which can be harsh on hair.
  • Though natural, some botanical ingredients can cause sensitivities in individuals with allergies.
  • May require multiple applications for intense color on darker, untreated hair.
  • Primarily available through professional salons. Limited accessibility for DIY enthusiasts.
  • Aveda’s color palette leans towards warm and neutral tones. 
  • Finding icy blondes or vibrant blues might be trickier.
  • The Aveda coloring process can be time-consuming due to the use of plant oils and longer processing times for some shades. 
  • Allergens like M-Aminophenol (Monoethanolamine), P-Aminophenol (Para-Aminophenol), Resorcinol, Toluene-2,5-Diamin Sulfate (Toluenediamine).
  • Harmful ingredients like Ammonium Hydroxide (Ammonia) and sodium Sulfite are present.

Redken Hair Color Review

Purple bottle of Redken Hair Color (Review)

Redken Chromatics is a permanent hair color range by Redken. It claims to be gentle on hair and offers full gray coverage. It is formulated with Redken’s ODS² (Oil Delivery System) + Protein Extract technology. This technology helps protect hair as well as deliver color pigments.

The revolutionary Zero Ammonia formula means no odor, no discomfort—just amazing color.

With an amazing range of shades, it has got you covered. Despite all these features, it is not cruelty-free and thus cannot be considered truly vegan. 

Ingredients:

Coloring Agents:

  • 2,4-Diaminophenoxyethanol Hcl: A dye intermediate for achieving dark and intense shades.
  • 2-Methylresorcinol: Dye precursor that helps create vibrant colors.
  • M-Aminophenol: Developer that helps color pigments react and penetrate the hair shaft.
  • Resorcinol: Powerful dye precursor for rich and vibrant colors, but can irritate scalp and eyes.
  • Toluene-2,5 Diamine: Potent dye precursor for dark and intense shades, but can cause allergic reactions.

Oxidants:

  • Thioglycerin: Reduces the hair’s natural color in preparation for dyeing.

Conditioning and Protective Ingredients:

  • Ascorbic Acid (Vitamin C): Antioxidant that helps protect hair from damage.
  • Cetyl Hydroxyethylcellulose: Thickener and film-forming agent that adds shine and manageability.
  • Deceth-5: Mild surfactant that helps cleanse and disperse color evenly.
  • EDTA: Chelating agent that binds to metal ions in water, preventing discoloration and ensuring color stability.
  • Oleth-10/Oleth-20: Emulsifiers that help blend the oil and water phases of the formula.
  • Proline: Amino acid that helps strengthen and repair hair.

Other Ingredients:

  • Aqua/Eau/Water: Main solvent in the formula.
  • Cetyl Palmitate: Thickener and emollient that adds smoothness and moisture.
  • Ethanolamine: pH adjuster that helps maintain the desired alkalinity for color development.
  • Mineral Oil: Emollient and moisturizer, but can be occlusive and trap heat.
  • Sodium Metabisulfite: Antioxidant and stabilizer that prevents premature oxidation of color components.
  • Threonine: Amino acid that helps strengthen and repair hair.

Pros:

  • Formulated with ODS² technology to protect hair 
  • The technology delivers color pigments efficiently. It minimizes damage.
  • Even for stubborn grays, it offers targeted conditioning. 
  • It respects hair’s natural lipid balance.
  • Zero Ammonia formula means no harsh odor or discomfort during coloring.
  • Wide range of colors including brunettes, reds, and blondes. 
  • This is perfect for a complete change or subtle highlights.
  • It leaves leaves hair two times more secure.  
  • It is two times smoother than before coloring.

Cons:

  • Expensive than mainstream ones. 
  • While effective, Redken Chromatics is likely intended for professional use. 
  • It requires a salon visit.
  • There’s a possibility of an allergic reaction. Patch testing is recommended.
  • Salon-grade products often come with a higher price tag, which might not be budget-friendly for everyone.
  • It involves chemical alteration and carries potential risks like hair damage or allergic reactions.
  • Permanent color requires maintenance. 
  • Includes root touch-ups and color-specific hair care routines.
  • The complex nature of the product might make at-home applications challenging for some individuals.
  • Allergens like 2,4-Diaminophenoxyethanol Hcl, M-Aminophenol (Monoethanolamine), Resorcinol, Toluene-2,5 Diamine.
  • Harmful ingredients like Ammonium (not explicitly listed, but often present in permanent hair color), Thioglycerin, Mineral Oil, and Sodium Metabisulfite.

Aveda vs Redken Hair Color: Comparison

Aspects Aveda hair Color Redken Hair Color
IngredientsUp to 99% naturally derived, plant-based oilsPatch test recommended, consult a stylist for damaged hair
DamageMinimalGentle on hair, but still uses chemicals
Gray coverageGoodExcellent
Color fadeFade-resistantVaries depending on the shade
Environmental impactUses plant power instead of petrochemicals, B Corp certifiedNot cruelty-free
PriceMore expensiveExpensive
AvailabilityPrimarily available through professional salonsAvailable in salons and some retail stores
Color rangeWide range, but leans towards warm and neutral tonesWide range, including vibrant colors
Processing timeCan be time-consumingVaries, and may require multiple applications
Suitability for DIYLimitedNot recommended for DIY
User ComplianceIdeal for sensitive scalps/eco-conscious consumersGood for odor-sensitive individuals
Customer SupportResponsive, professionalResponsive, professional
Long-Term BenefitsPotential for healthier hairProtects hair with protein extract
Precautions and ContraindicationsPatch test recommended, not ideal for drastic color changesPatch test recommended, consult stylist for damaged hair
Time to See ResultsVaries, may require multiple applicationsVaries
AllergensM-Aminophenol (Monoethanolamine), P-Aminophenol (Para-Aminophenol), Resorcinol, Toluene-2,5-Diamin Sulfate (Toluenediamine)2,4-Diaminophenoxyethanol Hcl, M-Aminophenol (Monoethanolamine), Resorcinol, Toluene-2,5 Diamine
Harmful IngredientsAmmonium Hydroxide (Ammonia), Sodium SulfiteAmmonium (not explicitly listed, but often present in permanent hair color), Thioglycerin, Mineral Oil, Sodium Metabisulfite

Final Verdict: Aveda vs Redken Hair Color

Now that we know all about both hair colors and have seen the Aveda vs Redken hair color comparison as well, we can form a final verdict to make your choice easier. Before that, we would recommend consulting your stylist before conclusion.

Aveda Hair Color:

  • Best for: Eco-conscious consumers, sensitive scalps, those seeking natural ingredients and minimal damage with warm/neutral color preferences.
  • Considerations: Higher price point, salon requirement, limited cool color options, and a time-consuming process.

Redken Hair Color:

  • Best for: Wider color range including vibrant options, excellent gray coverage, ammonia-free formula with faster processing times.
  • Considerations: Salon requirement, potential for allergic reactions, not cruelty-free, involves chemical alteration and maintenance required.

Here are some additional parameters to be considered:

  • Packaging and Presentation: Both brands offer sleek and professional packaging, with Aveda using more sustainable materials.
  • Ingredients and Transparency: Aveda wins for transparency and natural ingredients, while Redken uses advanced technology. 
  • Legal and Regulatory Compliance: Both brands adhere to safety standards, but Aveda goes further with B Corp certification and cruelty-free practices.
  • Affordability: Both are expensive, but Aveda is generally pricier.
  • User Compliance: Aveda is ideal for sensitive scalps and eco-conscious individuals, while Redken is good for those sensitive to odor.
  • Customer Support: Both offer responsive and professional customer service.
  • Allergen: Both recommend patch testing, with Aveda’s botanical ingredients potentially causing sensitivities.
  • Positive and Negative Reviews: Aveda praises shine, natural ingredients, and ethical practices, but critiques price, availability, and processing time. Redken gets accolades for gray coverage, color range, and ammonia-free formula, but faces backlash for cost, salon requirements, and potential damage.
  • Money Back Guarantee: Neither brand offers a universal money-back guarantee, but some salons may have individual policies.
  • Scientific Evidence: Both have research and development behind their technology, but Aveda emphasizes natural ingredients with potentially healthier long-term effects.
  • Value for Money: Depends on priorities. Aveda may offer better value for those prioritizing healthy hair and ethical practices, while Redken may be more valuable for those seeking specific colors and salon convenience.
  • Long-Term Benefits: Aveda’s natural ingredients offer the potential for healthier hair, while Redken’s protein extract provides some protection.
  • Time to See Results: Varies for both, with Aveda potentially requiring multiple applications for darker hair and longer processing times.

Ultimately, the choice is yours. Consider your budget, hair condition, desired color outcome, values, and priorities to make the best decision for yourself. Remember, a patch test is crucial before any treatment, regardless of the brand.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top